Commentary Logo
Japan Island disputes in SE Asia    World War III Alarm Anti-Islam video and anti-US sentiment    Skull Say no to brainwashing

       peace and anti-war Israel Iran strike imminent    sanctions as a result of nuclear tests Sanctions on Iran and workarounds    black lightning bolt India's massive blackout

Snapshots of news
Gearheads and mastheads
Home  •  About this site  •  How did we once fight corruption in colonial Hong Kong?
 •  Historical US administrative thoughts  •  USA versus colonial Hong Kong
 •  Anti-corruption review of Nigeria  •  Procurement monitoring in Nigeria
 •  Syndicated news  •  Usman's blog  •  Anti-graft news  •  Socialist news

 Sunday, September 22 2019 5:58am Hongkong Time

SKIP TO     Difference between Capital and Capitalism
On Taiwan: US-China relationsThe failure of the USSR
Contradictions in Chinese Socialism

Is Socialism dead?

Sidney J Gluck

Reproduced with permission of the copyright owner.

The crisis in Communist theory and practice does not spell the end of the socialist ideal. Socialism was not conceived by Marx. It had religious and utopian roots. Nor was the notion of class struggle a Marxian precept. It was born in bourgeois revolution.

When the "Manifesto" [1] was written in 1847, the word "socialism" was in such disrepute that the authors used "Communist Manifesto" to protect the substance of its historic view: "The history of all existing societies has been a history of class struggle." Today, "communism" is in such disrepute that it seeks refuge in "socialism" and "democratic socialism."

Marxism created a scientific approach to social change, and as with all uncharted courses and theories, it suffered from some historically conditioned misconceptions and shortcomings. Nonetheless, Lenin was able to lead a successful revolution in a backward country based on these principles and world view. He died before the new system was structured.

The forced march to industrialization and modern self-defense under Stalin did succeed in defeating fascism and the encirclement; but it did so at the expense of distorting socialist principles and negating its humanist and democratic premise. He combined Russian autocracy with Marxist misconceptions about the individual and the state and failed to heed Marx's own words about commodity production, market relations and "bourgeois right" in the development of socialism.

Stalinism was foisted on subsequent revolutions. Communist China, too, made considerable progress, having started from a much more backward condition and national fragmentation than Tsarist Russia. But it is only since the late 70s that China, and later the Soviet Union, came to recognize the need for restructuring, introducing high tech and new economic relations together with planning and expanding participation in decision-making.

The Soviet Union was a formidable power but did not release the individual creativeness of its citizens, hindering its development by structuring a paternalistic command regime. They ruled out a value-based market system, inhibiting integration with the world economy. High tech capabilities were allocated to military and space to the exclusion of industrial modernization and product development for civil society. Gorbachev's "Perestroika" [2a] needed time and accomplishments with backing of the "Party's" own economic ministers before launching "Glasnost" [2b] that drowned proposals for reforming production relations. The dominant Marxist ideology of government and the ruling Party dictatorship fell apart under the unrelenting attacks and machinations of Yeltsin, whose vision of change was "cowboy capitalism," not communism. In the midst of a nuclear balance of terror, restrained by the ABM Treaty between the two superpowers, the world had welcomed Gorbachev's initiative that promised more freedom in the USSR without abandoning socialism, more humane international relations, and a peaceful end to the Cold War without creating a single victorious hyperpower. But the Soviet model of 20th century socialism was doomed; the Russian giant could not compete. It bled to death.

China's Marxists, having aped the Soviet economic model at the outset in 1949, broke with the USSR in 1956, refusing to become the junior partner in a socialist alliance. Twenty years of struggle ensued within the Chinese Communist Party of China searching for new ways to build a socialist society. It was a period of dismal failures in the "Great Leap Forward" of the early 60's followed by the disruptive "Cultural Revolution" which ended in 1975 with the victory of creative veteran Marxist revolutionaries who had been protected and encouraged by Chou En Lai and guided by Deng Xiaoping who charted a course rooted in specific economic conditions and needs and of China's history and culture, in short, Socialism with Chinese Characteristics: modernization of means of production, value based exchange in a market system in synch with overall planning (micro/macro coordination), economic integration of the entire country, the release of individual entrepreneurial initiative, opening to the West for investment and trade, learning from capitalism, and integrating with the world economy.

Notwithstanding imbalances and excesses that require regulation or re-adjustments and correction, China has installed a classical primary level model of socialism, reflecting Marx' expression "from each according to ability, to each according to contribution."

A growing income gap that mirrors capitalism is yet to be dealt with while continuing the growth of national accumulation which translates into development, job creation, growth of high tech and labor intensive industry and raises the overall national standard of living.

In the Western capitalist world, the growing gulf between ultra-greed and degradation of workers (Adam Smith's dilemma over "loss of virtue") demands social intervention and struggle. Has class consciousness evaporated?

Ironically, the grand strategy of US foreign policy shifted with changes in the Socialist world. In 1972, Nixon sought alliance with China to tilt the triangle against the USSR; today the USA seeks to buy Russian cooperation in an effort to tilt the triangle towards containment of China. That speaks well for Chinese Socialism. It is an independent, anti-imperialist developing country well on its way to modernization. It is accepted as an economic partner in the world economy and in regional cooperation. It garnered allies in support of taking its rightful seat in the UN Security Council in 1972. It won an invitation to join the World Trade Organization and, most recently, Beijing won the bid to host the International Olympics in 2008 [3].

It is necessary to review political and economic history and the theories of scientific socialism from today's perspective to ascertain what is alive, what is new and what is dead in the inescapable march to a more humane society that affords its workers and "middle class" of all races and gender a just share in employment and the product of their labors and a truly democratic voice in directing the destiny of nations - which remains the vision of Socialism.

August 1, 2001


Professor Sidney J Gluck is former chairman, New York Chapter, US-China Peoples Friendship Association; emeritus professor with the Social Science Faculty, New School For Social Research; and is currently chairman, US-China Society of Friends.

Email Sidney at sjgluck {at} aol {dot} com

SKIP TO     Difference between Capital and Capitalism
On Taiwan: US-China relationsThe failure of the USSR
Contradictions in Chinese Socialism

Note 1: See "Manifesto of the Communist Party" by Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels, published in late 1847, at (or download PDF backup (389KB)) See also the Sri Lanka Guardian artcle on "Is socialism dying?" by Shyamon Jayasinghe dated September 8. 2012.

Note 2a: "Perestroika", reconstruction.

Note 2b: "Glasnost", open, intellectual talk.

Note 3: In 1990, when this essay was first written, the writer shared the prevailing optimism with the following paragraph: "The world has welcomed the changes initiated under Gorbachev because they are bringing about an end to the cold war and we are witnessing the inevitable consequences in Eastern Europe. But is socialism dead? The USSR remains a formidable power and China pursues its socialist goal while opening to the West. Socialist and Communist parties in the West still confront governments wracked with crises, competition and slow growth. The growing gulf between ultra-greed and slow degradation (Adam Smith's dilemma) demands social intervention. Has class consciousness evaporated?" The writer hopes that China maintains its independent anti-imperialist course for a victory of Socialism in the 21st century.

Commentary and reflection pages by Raymond Cheng, PhD DPA FRSA

  Main • Commentary   Special Foci • Syndicated News | Corruption | Socialism | GuanXi

  Health Related • Traditional Chinese Medicine   Others • OXLL

© 1997-2018 The Commentary by Office of Dr Raymond Cheng. All rights reserved. Copyright of selected news articles, the headlines and logos belongs to the respective entities. Read disclaimer

Digital platform powered by Wyith Limited, Wyith Institute. Wyith Limited and Wyith Institute are associated businesses operated by the Office of Dr Raymond Cheng • Dr Raymond Cheng & Partners Ltd and The Commentary Ltd.

Home  •  About this site  •  How did we once fight corruption in colonial Hong Kong?
 •  Historical US administrative thoughts  •  USA versus colonial Hong Kong
 •  Anti-corruption review of Nigeria  •  Procurement monitoring in Nigeria
 •  Syndicated news  •  Usman's blog  •  Anti-graft news  •  Socialist news

Contact the editor at raymond {dot} cheng {at} kellogg {dot} oxon {dot} org

The RendezvousBuildersCommentatorsContributorsReadersResearchers
Reflection Pages • Miscellaneous Stuff
The difference between instant evaluation and improving recognition – November 20
Freddy Krueger revisited: Politically correct education? – October 23
From the evaluator's perspective: Justified conclusions and decisions – October 8
Online and distance learning degrees – evaluator's perspective – September 25
The moment fake degrees turned recognized and appraised – September 9

Photo credits for top title bar, from left to right: Iza H (Work), Lukasz Gumowski (Blue balls), Marcin Bania (Smiling and naked), Lautaro Gonda (Milan station), Jan Abt (Girl taking a picture), Daniel Tang (Hot switch), Barbara Henry (Moriah reading), Ralf Herrmann (Checkmate II), Marko Roeper (Led #4), Ian Russell (Girl in downtown LA).
Note: Animated GIF graphics and clipart obtained from,,, and Sketches, cartoons and other handdrawings courtesy of Alice-the-Artist.

Special Alert! This is *NOT* the American Jewish Committee's Commentary Magazine! Special notice! This is not the American Jewish Committee's Commentary Magazine nor are we in any way affiliated with them. To visit AJC's magazine, please go to instead, thank you for your attention.
Memo with pin Technical memos for members
Receiving using Gmail | Sending using Gmail
0x800ccc0e | 0x800ccc19 | 0x800ccc79

This site is best viewed with Microsoft® Internet Explorer 6.0 or above, minimum 1024x768 16M color-depth resolution. The Commentary Group and its personnel do not endorse external sites and are not responsible for the content of these websites. All external sites will open in a new browser window.

COUNT ON THE STATISTICS  100% Towels (c) Daniel Chittka
Photo © Daniel Chittka

This new section contains some interesting statistics in bribe and corruption, please check back for more as we pile up our numbers!

It's statistics time!  Using n-gram: kickback, graft, bribe and corruption - Comparison of their historical occurrences from 1810 to 2009 A.D.

  The word guanxi (collocation) and meanings of bribe: Deeply rooted, disgusting, sad endings

Looking for a good book (c) Doug Logan
Photo © Doug Logan
tagged by area of interestBY AREA OF INTEREST
Pragmatics: Politeness trends from the historical perspective of global trade
Computer mediated communications: Social network – Came riding the waves of amazing coincidences
Language acquisition:
A critique on "A corpus driven study of the potential for vocabulary learning through watching movies"

Grammatical analysis: "When a linguist stumbled upon a Buttonwood"
Lexicon and the corpus: "John Sinclair's lexical items – an introduction"
tagged by regionBY REGION • Anything AsiaUS Presence in Asia
ChinaTaiwanHong Kong and MacauJapanKoreaSingaporeMalaysiaPhilippinesPakistanIndiaAfghanistanVietnam, Laos, Cambodia, Thailand and MyanmarTimor-Leste and IndonesiaMongoliaNew Zealand and Australia
tagged by topicsBY TOPIC • BiofuelRhino and elephant poachingAmerican movies hit China marketChina Internet censorshipChina's outward FDI opportunitiesGlobal rice yield
Island disputes in Southeast Asia | Senkakus-Diaoyu and historical findings | Dokdo-Takeshima | Spratly, Paracel, Scarborough | Kurils

For those you who don't have time to read all our news excerpts about the Asian island disputes (links above), you may find the following video, "The economic impact of a war between Japan and China", very enlightening.

© Minute MBA: More from

Free Pussy Riot!
Free Pussy Riot!

Photo © Igor Mukhin, retrieved from Wikipedia

"This trial is another example of the Kremlin's attempts to discourage and delegitimize dissent. It is likely to backfire." John Dalhuisen, Director of Amnesty International's Europe and Central Asia Programme

 More from Amnesty InternationalFree Pussy Riot

How it started – Pussy Riot Prayers, February 2012

08/17 Pussy Riot imprisoned on hooliganism charges
08/17 The only professionals in sight
08/19 Pussy Riot protesters arrested in Marseille
08/20 NZ PM – Sentence 'disproportionate'
08/20 Pussy Riot fear their kids being put in care
08/22 German supporters face criminal charges
08/22 Pussy Riot – it's carefully calibrated
08/23 Russian church-state corruption unveiled
08/23 Putin's secret weapon: The Orthodox faithful
08/24 Putin-nominated watchdog slams convictions
08/31 'Pussy Riot ritual killing', man detained
09/03 Orthodox deacon speaks over verdict
09/06 Putin denies part in 'Pussy Riot case'
09/10 Pussy Riot benefit concert draws 1,000
09/10 Gorbachev says verdict "disproportionate"
09/19 Punk group to transfer to remote penal colony
09/21 Aung San calls on Moscow to release RP
10/01 Sentence appeal delayed until Oct 10
10/10 Katya freed, 2 years for Nadya and Masha
10/16 Masha and Nadya sent to remote labor prison

BBC • Pussy Riot women begin life in prison

11/16 Merkel challanges Putin on imprisonment
11/22 Maria Alekhina transferred to solitary cell
11/28 Tolokonnikova's appeal case goes to court
12/24 Extremist videos appeal adjourned

01/15 Masha's sentence deferment denied
02/01 PR civil claim granted right to appeal
02/07 Pussy Riot files complaint with ECHR
03/06 Ombudsman asks court to overturn verdict
03/08 Protesters detained in Moscow
04/13 PR gets reprimand: parole problematic
04/21 PR defense seeks abolition of conviction
07/26 Parole denied, PR remains defiant

The Knife supporting PR at Pukkelpop

08/17 Against verdict on PR – Day of Solidarity
08/23 PR seeks mitigation of remaining sentence
GLUCK ON SOCIALISM AND CHINA Asia (c) Robert Churchill
Photo © Robert Churchill

Professor Sidney Gluck (c) Sandi BachomI am honored to have obtained Professor Sidney Gluck's (right) permission to allow me to repost here some of his work and interview related to China and socialism. Professor Gluck is professor emertius at the New School University in New York. A classical Marxist, Gluck has been studying China for 60 years in history and modern development. He has lectured all over the U.S. and still welcomes engagement at the age of 94 – photo © Sandi Bachom


Usman Khurshid on Mike McCune's HD Monitor with Paths logo with Maartje van Caspel's Public Space
I am proud to announce that the website is now carrying the technology updates from Usman Khurshid's Usman is a network consultant and works in a mixed environment of Windows and Linux platforms. He likes to study about the latest advancements in computer technology and shares his views on his blog.

Click here to read Usman's tech blog
Subscribe to RSS feed
Photo © Usman Khurshid, Mike McCune, Maartje van Caspel
COMING 2019 – COMPUTING CORPUS Active Network Hub (c) Phil Sigin-Lavdanski
Photo © Phil Sigin-Lavdanski

Oh, please do not get me wrong. This new section is not about computers, electronics or any engineering stuff, but rather I am currently constructing a new corpus based on Spectrum, the monthly publication from the Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers USA, from July 2007 to date. Having been a member for over 20 years since 1992, I am always fascinated by some of the terms scientists use when they talk about or envision their new inventions or methodologies. How many of them eventually come into practice? Could there be some insights we could possibly derive, from the linguistics perspective?


This website is published and designed by Raymond Cheng, PhD DPA and reflects only his personal views and opinions in his individual capacity. It does not represent the views and opinions of his firm, employer(s), students, etc., and is not in any way sponsored or endorsed by any other thrid parties. Click here to read my full disclaimer

Share on Twitter  Add to Facebook  Share on LinkedIn  +1 on Google